Not a Creature Was Stirring... Then, Guess What I Found Out?
Very early in the holiday rush—long before the real chaos should have started—I realized something was off. This is normally the time of year when I’m buried in orders, bringing in friends to help, tracking down UPS shipments, assuring frantic holiday shopper that their orders would arrive on time. Instead, my shop was quiet.
It wasn’t the usual suspects.
Not a slow week - it was the height of the usual Christmas rush.
Not a weird algorithm dip - Traffic was up over last year
My sales didn’t just soften. They fell straight through the floor.
Dropped.
Plummeted.
Tanked. Down 54% year over year.
I had a 7 day sales window where sales dropped 78% over the previous year.
Devastating.
The kind of drop you feel in your stomach before you even see the numbers.
And that’s when the confusion set in — because nothing on my end had changed. In fact I had been working since July to prepare for this. I’d improved listings, upgraded photos, tightened tags, invested in ads, built a Meta campaign, added free shipping, ran sales, participated in all the Etsy special promos and pushed harder than ever. This should have been my strongest season.
Instead, it felt like someone had quietly unplugged my shop.
I didn’t know it yet, but this was the first sign of a much larger pattern I’d been seeing across the marketplace — a pattern I would later recognize as the early fingerprints of what I now call Shadow Shell Shops.
But at the time, I just knew something was wrong.
So I went looking.
The Pattern I Wasn’t Supposed to Notice
I started where any seller would: search results, categories, competitors, keywords I’ve tracked for years. And that’s when things got strange.
The stores didn't have about pages
7 year old shops with reviews that only go back a year
Shop with international phone numbers and Gmail addresses in the header
Yet somehow they were outranking established sellers overnight.
Their listings looked… Similar. Way too similar.
None of these images would even come close to passing Etsy's primary image guidelines. So what was happening here?
Same images.
Same products.
Same “handmade” claims.
Everything list priced under $20
Same AI generated model photos
Everything marked down 25-45% off
Same layered text "Custom any Order"
Same messy, junky, cluttered rendered images
And the shipping times?
Processing time 1-3 days
Shipping time - 1-3 weeks
Let’s just say they didn’t match the “handmade in the USA” story being told.
I didn’t know if these shops were full Shadow Shell Shops yet — but the behaviors were eerily similar. The same tells. The same inconsistencies. The same identical looking mockups. These were for items that were fully customized, cut and sew, embroidery, tackle twill. I've been in this business 30 years. I know what it costs to make things in this country - these prices didn't reflect that.
I had to start somewhere - and I noticed one that caught my eye. KXK.
The First Thread: KXKCustomShop
Ships from... California, "🖐🏿Made" in... China...
KXK wasn’t new to me. I’d seen them around for years — on Amazon, on Facebook, on Google Shopping. They were everywhere. A massive “custom jersey” brand with endless variations, stock-photo templates, and prices in the $30–$40 range. They were also one of the first big factories I saw migrate to U.S. marketplaces after Amazon shut down its China third‑party pipeline due to rampant fraud — part of that wave of sellers who suddenly appeared stateside almost overnight.
These were the kind of listings you scroll past because you already know exactly what they are: cheap imports, fast turnaround, factory pipeline.
So why were they on Etsy?
Why would a company that size — with a full-blown presence across multiple platforms — bother setting up shop on a marketplace supposedly built for handmade creators?
And not just “on Etsy,” but thriving on Etsy.
Dominating categories.
Ranking high.
Selling nonstop.
All while claiming to be handmade.
It didn’t add up.
KXK wasn’t a scrappy maker sewing jerseys in a garage.
They were a brand — a large-scale, multi-platform, mass-production operation based in China.
So seeing them on Etsy felt like déjà vu.
Here they were again.
Same products.
Same photos.
Same prices.
Same everything.
Except now they were wearing a “handmade” label.
If this was just a handful of small shops cutting corners, I’d find out quickly.
If this was something bigger — something systemic — KXK would be the perfect place to start.
So I dug in.
When I Looked Closer, Nothing Added Up
The deeper I went into their Etsy shop, the stranger it got.
They claimed to be handmade.
They claimed to be U.S.‑based.
They claimed to be a small shop.
The about page - 6 words long.
But the numbers told a different story.
They’d apparently been on Etsy for seven years — yet almost all of their sales had happened in the last 12 months. Their volume was enormous, far beyond what any handmade shop could realistically produce. Their turnaround times were impossibly fast. Their prices were factory‑level. And their shipping location? Ukiah California.
No shop photos or owner profile
No production partners.
No business registration number.
Nothing that matched the scale of what they were selling.
It was like looking at a résumé where every line contradicted the next.
I didn’t know yet whether KXK’s Etsy storefront was a full Shadow Shell Shop, renting out a small Etsy approved maker space and running it remotely from overseas. 7 years on Etsy but sales and reviews only going back a year? The fingerprints were there.
At that point, I had two choices:
Walk away and pretend I didn’t see it…
or follow the thread.
So I reached out to the listed store owner, Xiaohong Lin
The Conversation That Confirmed Everything
I didn’t expect much when I messaged the Etsy shop. Just a few basic questions. I wanted to confirm if this was someone just using the KXK shop name without their knowledge or if it was connected to the business. A little clarity. I expected to get a canned response to fulfill the Star Seller requirement and then silence.
Instead, I got a full confession.
I asked about a bulk order — 240 jerseys. I said I needed them made in the U.S. and referenced their Etsy listing, which claimed to ship from Ukiah, California.
Her response?
“We are a local store in the United States. But our factory is in China, where labor is relatively cheap and manufacturing is more developed…”
They offered me a 20% discount. Free shipping via DHL. And a promise that the jerseys would be produced and shipped directly from China.
I pressed again.
I asked why the listing said California.
Why it didn’t mention China.
Why there was no production partner.
Why the “handmade” label was still there.
Their answer?
“We are an American company, but our factory is in China… I don’t want to deceive you because some customers have strict requirements for the shipping location.”
I asked if they were a reseller.
If they worked for KKX.
If they were just placing orders through the brand.
They clarified:
“We are a KKX direct operated store, not a distributor… All the jerseys will be produced directly at the KKX factory and then shipped to customers.”
No middlemen.
No handmade production.
No U.S. workshop.
Just a direct pipeline from a Chinese factory to an Etsy storefront labeled “handmade.”
And there it was.
The confirmation I needed.
The proof I couldn’t ignore.
The moment the illusion collapsed.
The Implications: This Wasn’t a One-Off
KXK wasn’t a glitch.
They weren’t an exception.
They weren’t a misunderstanding.
They were a case study — the first thread I pulled in what would become a much larger investigation.
Because once you see the pattern, you can’t unsee it.
The same photos.
The same warehouses.
The same “handmade” labels.
The same impossible volume.
The same sudden surge in sales.
The same lack of transparency.
The same pipeline.
KXK was simply the first shop willing to say the quiet part out loud.
Etsy’s Silence Says More Than Their Policies Do
I reported all of it to Etsy in December: the message thread, the handmade badge, the admissions, the evidence trail — every single piece.
Their response — Nothing.
KXK is still on Etsy - still cranking out the Chinese products.
And as of January 9, 2026 KXKCustomShop, according to Etsy is still 100% "🖐🏿Made".
The Beginning of the Bigger Story
KXK was the first thread I pulled — but it wasn’t the last.
In the weeks that followed, I uncovered multiple storefronts with identical patterns: shared warehouses, shared photos, shared business registration numbers, shared pipelines, shared operators. No production partners yet massive sales all while claiming, (or Etsy assigning) their products are Hand Made.
This story is part of an ongoing investigation into Etsy’s growing network of factory‑run storefronts — and the handmade sellers being buried beneath them.
More threads are coming.
More stories.
More evidence.
More names.
But for now, this is where the unraveling began.
And while I’m pulling these threads, I’m also trying to stay relevant myself — navigating Etsy’s cryptic guidelines, and avoiding the constant risk of being downgraded by Etsy’s bots. Real makers are fighting on two fronts: the factories flooding the marketplace, and the automated systems that punish the people actually doing the work, not just creating listings all day long.
If you want the next chapter — the next receipts, the next wave of evidence —
join the group: